Double Manslaughter Conviction for Construction Firm

Posted on August 22, 2016

A construction contractor has been fined £550,000 for the corporate manslaughter of two men who fell through a roadside hoarding and into a site in Euston, north London.

Monavon Construction pleaded guilty to two counts of corporate manslaughter and breaching Section 3 (1) of the Health & Safety at Work Act. British Transport Police officer Gavin Brewer, 32, and television producer Stuart Meads, 34, had been out drinking together. The pair was seen on CCTV walking along a street in the early hours of the morning on 19 October 2013.

They started arguing and one pushed the other against the building site perimeter hoarding that was on Netley Street at the junction with Hamstead Road, the hoarding gave way and Brewer and Meads fell head first, 4m down an uncovered light well that was part of a basement flat under construction by Monavon.

The two men sustained fatal head and neck injuries and were pronounced dead at the scene. Oliver Glasgow QC, prosecuting, said the hoarding was not of sufficient height or strength, and for at least two months there had been no cover on the light well. He said there were many occasions in the days leading up to the accident when access to the site was unprotected.

The Metropolitan Police and the Health and Safety Executive launched a joint investigation and found that the hoardings had been fixed in such a way that only negligible force would have been required to make then give way.

Sentencing, Judge Paul Worsley QC said the deaths were an “accident waiting to happen” and “wholly preventable”. “This was not an isolated incident – the course must mark this by fines that I accept are heavy,” he said.

At the Old Bailey on 27 June Monavon, which has an annual turnover of around £500,000, was fined £250,000 for each offence plus £50,000 for the health and safety breach. The fines must be paid in two years. It was given six months to pay £23,653 in prosecution costs.